The crux seems to be Newmans assertion that scientists are pessimistic about people and have made vast and belittling claims about human life. Reading between the lines, I think I know what he means. And I sympathise. Robert Newman: Scientists think were all stupid. The universe discovered by science appears vast, impersonal and purposeless. And human beings, we now know, evolved on this planet mostly by accident, and live and breathe and have their being thanks to the complex operations of cells and molecules that, despite all the progress, we are still a long way from figuring out completely. The cosmological expansion of the universe and the relentless reductionism of the life sciences have certainly changed how we see our place in the world. Get the factsAnd yes, perhaps scientists do sometimes talk too delightedly about the pieces of the jigsaw puzzle at the expense of more holistic considerations. But it would be wrong to see that as a blithe dismissal of the beauty and significance of human existence. Often, its quite the reverse. As physicist Richard Feynman has argued, science has the power to intensify our appreciation of the wonder of the world and, by extension, of human life.
For the original version including any supplementary images or video, visit https://www.theguardian.com/science/occams-corner/2017/apr/18/rob-newman-thinks-scientists-belittle-people-i-sympathise-science-is-unsettling